BDO has added a statutory recommendation on state aid and company loans to its reports on Woking's 2019 to 2023 accounts. Councillors see them on 19 November.

The auditor of Woking Borough Council’s accounts for 2019/20 to 2022/23 has added a formal recommendation to its final reports. It says the council still has not done something the government’s own review asked of it in 2023.

The recommendation is made under Section 27 of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014. It was not in the draft reports BDO LLP presented in December 2025. The council published the refreshed reports on 11 November, for its Audit and Governance Committee on Thursday 19 November (Woking Borough Council, BDO external audits report).

What the auditor recommends

BDO’s wording, quoted in the council’s report, is:

The finance and governance review undertaken by DLUHC [in 2023] recommended that the Council review its position on subsidy/state aid and best consideration with regard to its wholly owned companies and review and reassess the legal position of the structure of company financing arrangements. We have not seen any evidence that the Council has implemented this recommendation.

In plain terms, the question is whether lending to its own companies, such as the Thameswey group, broke the rules on state aid and on getting the best price. The 2019/20 completion report says some loans to related parties were made “at below commercial rates which may be in contravention of EU State Aid Law”. BDO says it could not determine whether they were (BDO, 2019/20 audit completion report).

The council’s answer

The council’s response, set out in the committee report, is that it is now getting out of those companies rather than reviewing them. It says it is doing so “under the instruction of Government”, through its Asset Rationalisation Plan. It seeks subsidy control advice where needed during that work and expects that “once the ARP is complete, any historic state aid/subsidy control issues will have been negated”.

The report lists what the council has done since 2023:

  • worked with government-appointed commissioners on its Improvement and Recovery Programme
  • ended the revolving credit facilities that had been financing the companies
  • accepted the findings of Grant Thornton’s Public Interest Report and carried out its recommendations
  • pressed on with its Asset Rationalisation Plan, with work ongoing to get out of past investments

It also points out that the recommendation comes more than six years after the end of 2019/20. BDO gave an unqualified opinion on the 2018/19 accounts.

Four years, no opinion

The reports confirm what BDO told councillors last December. For all four years, 2019/20 to 2022/23, it gives a disclaimer of opinion: it cannot say whether the accounts are free of material misstatement.

On value for money, it gives an adverse conclusion for 2019/20 and reports significant weaknesses in the following three years. Among the weaknesses it lists for 2019/20:

  • a lack of internal controls over loans to subsidiaries, which led to misstated loan and investment figures
  • a lack of controls over the Housing Revenue Account, with general fund transactions processed through it

BDO’s 2019/20 report puts the disclaimer down to a “management-imposed limitation of scope”. The council disputes that. In a letter to BDO dated 24 August, its Strategic Director for Finance, Stephen Fitzgerald, said it was not reasonable to blame management for a disclaimer issued more than six years after the year it covers (Woking Borough Council, response to BDO, 24 August 2026).

The letter also complains about the time taken. The 2019/20 accounts went on the council’s website on 1 September 2020. “In total, BDO have taken six years to issue this disclaimed opinion,” it says. It adds that several problems the report mentions were found by the council’s own reviews, not by the audit.

What it has cost

BDO’s 2019/20 report shows an audit fee of £42,121 for that year. On top of that it lists an estimated additional audit fee of £230,000, against £65,000 for 2018/19.

Why it is still not finished

The opinions cannot be signed yet. A local resident objected to the 2019/20 and 2020/21 accounts, over how the council accounted for its minimum revenue provision, the money set aside each year to repay debt. BDO says it has now responded to the objection. A 21-day period for any further legal action then has to pass before the opinions can be signed and published.

The committee is asked to receive the opinions and reports, and to let the finance director and the committee chair sign off the final steps. The council says finishing BDO’s work should let Grant Thornton complete the audits from 2023/24 onwards.

What it means for you

The council’s own report says it cannot return to a timely audit cycle until these four years are closed. That matters for the next step too: Woking Borough Council is replaced by the new West Surrey Council on 1 April 2027 (Woking Borough Council).

The loans at the heart of the recommendation are the same ones behind the council’s debts. Our report on the Thameswey housing loans being written down has the figures.

The meeting is on Thursday 19 November. The agenda and papers are on the council’s committee page.